Food Hygiene Rating Sticker on a food business window to allow consumers to see the standard achieved by the business and feel confident in safety standards

Food Hygiene Rating Scheme – should it be mandatory in England?

Should Display of Food Hygiene Rating Be Mandatory in England?

Since its launch in 2010, the Food Hygiene Rating Scheme (FHRS), developed by the Food Standards Agency (FSA), has become a cornerstone of food safety transparency in the UK. Designed to help consumers make informed choices about where to eat, the scheme assigns food businesses a rating from 0 (urgent improvement needed) to 5 (very good) based on hygiene standards.

While the scheme is well-established, one question continues to spark debate:
Should it be mandatory for businesses in England to display their food hygiene rating? The Chartered Institute of Environmental Health certainly believes so.

Understanding the Food Hygiene Rating Scheme

The FHRS is underpinned by the Brand Standard, which ensures consistency in how ratings are awarded across local authorities. Ratings are based on three key criteria:

  1. Food Handling – How food is prepared, cooked, cooled, reheated, and stored.
  2. Structural Requirements – Cleanliness, layout, lighting, ventilation, pest control, and facilities.
  3. Confidence in Management – Food safety systems, staff training, and compliance history.

Environmental Health Officers (EHOs) conduct inspections and assign ratings, following the Brand Standard to ensure fairness and consistency across regions. While England, Wales, and Northern Ireland use the same FHRS Brand Standard, Scotland operates a separate system: the Food Hygiene Information Scheme.

The Display Debate: What the Data Shows

In Wales and Northern Ireland, it is a legal requirement for food businesses to display their hygiene rating in a prominent location. In England, however, display remains voluntary, leading to frustration among consumers and businesses alike.

Display Rates by Country (2023 FSA Audit)1

  • Wales: 92% of businesses displayed their rating visibly
  • Northern Ireland: 91% compliance
  • England: Only 69% of businesses displayed their rating

Online Display

Despite widespread use of platforms like Facebook and Instagram, businesses are reluctant to display their rating online1:

  • 10% of English businesses
  • 5% in Northern Ireland
  • 8% in Wales
    displayed their rating online

Why Mandatory Display Matters

Consumer Protection and Transparency

When a business displays their rating it shows the consumer that the business is in fact on the EHO’s radar – regardless of the actual rating achieved. Consumers can then rely on visible ratings to make safe choices.

Business Incentives

  • 76% of UK food businesses now hold a rating of 5, showing the scheme’s positive impact on hygiene standards. For many larger businesses, the achievement of a % rating is part of a manager’s KPI. Boards study the results to be reassured that standards are being achieved.
  • A study found that in England 86% of these FHRS 5 businesses thought mandatory display was a good idea.1 

Challenges to Mandatory Display in England

Delayed Re-Ratings

Businesses that improve after receiving a low score may wait weeks or months for a re-inspection, leaving them stuck with a poor rating even though they may have made the necessary improvements.

Inconsistent Costs

Revisit fees vary by local authority, creating an uneven playing field.

Resource Constraints

Local authorities often lack the staff and budget to conduct timely revisits, especially in rural areas.

Levelling the Playing Field: Suggested Solutions

To support mandatory display, the following measures could help ensure fairness:

  • Standardised Revisit Timelines – e.g., maximum wait of 30 days
  • Uniform Revisit Fees – a flat rate across all local authorities
  • Freelance EHOs – contracted professionals to handle re-inspections and ensure there is no delay or backlog
  • Set Fee + Mileage Model – businesses pay a transparent, consistent and fair fee

Conclusion

The FHRS has significantly improved food hygiene standards across the UK. Making display mandatory in England would enhance transparency, protect consumers, and reward compliant businesses. But to do so fairly, the system must be supported by consistent policies and adequate resources.

With 76% of businesses already achieving top ratings, and strong public support for mandatory display, the time may be right for England to follow the lead of Wales and Northern Ireland.

References

  1. FSA Audit of Display and Business Survey 2023
  2. Global Food Consumers Forum – Display Rates

 

Scroll to Top